
I have to make a confession. Nothing makes me more angry than meandering acoustic singer-songwriters and aging men with hair metal fatigue
trying to pull off Van Halen solo's in cover bands.
Seriously, both those things are wrong in every way imaginable. The conjure feelings of "intense red" and bring to the forefront memories of when I studied sound engineering some years ago.
The timing was all my fault though; my interest was touched at about the same time every dickhead in his wonderfully tooled two bedroom apartment in Dublin actually thought that they could
be Damien Rice. Oh the foolishness...
There are three things that need to be referenced before I go ahead with this review though:
- As stated above, I have found many singer/songwriters over the years to be deeply irritating knobs with intensely elevated sense of self-worth;
- You loved, you lost - could I care?? No, I really, really couldn't - maybe you lost, because of the soft, spineless world you inhabit? Admittedly when it comes to certain forms of music, I become Davros from Doctor Who and in this case hair-metal and piss-poor sing-songwriters are Thals, while these typing digits and soldier-like words are the new Daleks (probably better if you just look it up).
- In a not-very-interesting turn of events, I am somewhat partial to Lily Allen's first two albums, but does she qualify as a pop-starlet or singer-songwriter??
...but maybe that's just me.
Bomb in a Birdcage is the second album from LA-based 24-year-old Alison Sudol (aka - A Fine Frenzy). Let it be said now that A Fine Frenzy was made - built if you will, laboratory like - for Grey's Anotomy and it's ilk - with songs therein contain just the right amount of schmaltz to be perfect for "an emotional scene", while not being so spectacular to actually stand above a show.
Just imagine all the garbage that Coldplay have produced over the years and you get the idea. It's style is summery without resorting to sugar-coated bullshit, yet is still quite fine the likes TodayFM and the nation's office drones.
There are temptations to ring in comparisons with KT Tunstell (
yes!) Jose Gonzales (
very no!) in that every song is structured and performed very well; however the songs talk and talk and talk, yet say absolutely nothing memorable.
"What I Wouldn't Do" and "Electric Twist" are nice, jaunty upbeat numbers that play out pleasantly enough, although the outro to "Electric Twist" goes on for far too long. On the other hand, I have no memory of "New Heights" even though I only heard it few moments ago.
These are followed by the singles "Blow Away" and "Happier" - I have to admit that "Blow Away" surprised me as a choice for lead single as it simply does not stand out at all, while it does slot very neatly into the album itself. "Happier" is a little better, although still not a stand-out, but I could swear during the opening few bars, someone is attempting an acoustic version of the intro to "Kids" by MGMT.
Like "New Heights", "Swan Song" drifts under the radar in a way that I have no recollection of hearing it only moments after it finished; however that is followed by "Elements", which is easily the most impressive song on the album - if only because Sudol has widened the instrument range for this song. It is also - notably - the first time on the album she really lets her vocals rip.
Both "The World Without" and "Bid of the Summer" are nice enough songs without really drumming up any excess thought or excitement - it is only then that I realise that the album has drifted into its latter third. Yep, fillerville... Without being mean, it really is a struggle to see where a lot of these songs can go without eventually becoming a form of aural wallpaper. OK, scratch that, because "Stood Up" is a quite a good song and something of a departure from the rest of the album as it plays with it's instrumentation and dynamics in ways that the rest simply doesn't.
The album closes with "The Beacon" - a simple number which is mostly just Sudol's vocals over piano and synth (and a little bit of wandering trumpet) and in terms of closures, it is rather good in a TV-advertised way and is slightly reminiscent of "Motion Picture Soundtrack by Radiohead - only for Coldplay fans...
Sudol has been at pains to point out that Bomb in a Birdcage is more of "band" effort than a solo-work and it's quite correct. There is definitely much more going on in terms musical dynamics, as if two or three different people were involved in its arrangement and eventual execution (more than likely the case); however this isn't necessarily a good thing too as there are occasions when this just sounds like Keane with a different singer - and that is
never a good thing.
This is (believe it or not) a pretty OK album; however if you have absolutely no imagination whatsoever, it'll probably be your album of the year, while more discerning folk will sweep it under the carpet in a vain hope that it'll cease to exist.
If there was a set genre for American-soap music, this would slot right in, but
Bomb in a Birdcage may have to be content with swimming in a sea of pop-rock / radio-friendly brainless filler that BBC Radio is so fond repeating ad-finitum. It is music for the ER / Grey's Anatomy generation, but not so bad that it would ever warrant a place in Friends.
Have I mentioned yet that I despise the TV show Friends with such vigour and contempt that whenever I hear the theme tune, I vomit a little inside? No?? I'll save that one for later...
myspace.com/afinefrenzyRating: 3 out of 5
Leigh